Colts vs Cowboys Prediction & Betting Tips for NFL Week 9 on 11/8/2026

The Dallas Cowboys are set to take on the Indianapolis Colts in Week 9 of the 2026 NFL regular season. The game will be hosted at Lucas Oil Stadium, home to the Colts, with a retractable roof to shield against the very cold forecast. The action kicks off at 1:00 PM and will be broadcast on FOX.

Brian Schottenheimer's Cowboys enter this game with a 3-5 record, hoping to improve their standing in the NFC East. They have shown mixed results on the road with a 2-2 record, making this a critical opportunity for them to gain momentum. The Cowboys recently faced the Arizona Cardinals, narrowly losing with a score of 33-30.

Shane Steichen's Colts, with a 2-6 record, are looking to turn their season around in front of a home crowd. Currently, they stand 1-2 at home and aim to leverage this game to regain some footing in the AFC South. Their last outing resulted in a heavy 42-7 loss against the Jacksonville Jaguars.

According to consensus odds, the Cowboys are favored with a moneyline of -263 and a spread of -5.5. The over/under is set at 51.5, suggesting expectations of a high-scoring game. Both teams will need to overcome recent struggles to secure a much-needed win.

Colts vs Cowboys At a Glance (Week 9)

• The Dallas Cowboys have a 3-5 record this season and a 2-2 record on the road.
• The Indianapolis Colts hold a 2-6 record this season with a 1-2 record at home.
• This is a Week 9 regular season game set to be played at Lucas Oil Stadium in Indianapolis.
• The weather forecast indicates a very cold day with clear skies, but the retractable roof may minimize wind impact.
• The Cowboys are favored with a -263 moneyline, while the Colts have a +216 moneyline.
• The point spread is set at Cowboys -5.5 and Colts +5.5, with the total points over/under at 51.5.

Indianapolis Colts Gear Up for a Home Challenge Against the Cowboys

Offensive Overview

The Indianapolis Colts have been struggling offensively this season, ranking 24th in total offensive yards with an average of 291.1 yards per game. Their passing game is particularly concerning, standing 27th with 174.6 yards per game.

However, the rushing attack offers a glimmer of hope, ranking 10th in the league with 932 rushing yards. Jonathan Taylor's performance has been crucial, accumulating 610 rushing yards and 8 touchdowns in the season so far.

Defensive Performance

The Colts' defense has faced its share of challenges, allowing an average of 27.8 points per game, which ranks them 28th in the league. They've also struggled against the run, allowing 131.8 rushing yards per game, ranking 27th.

On a positive note, the Colts have shown an ability to get to the quarterback, recording 16 sacks, ranking 11th. Players like Jaylahn Tuimoloau and Laiatu Latu have been instrumental in this aspect of the game.

Key Players to Watch

Quarterback Daniel Jones leads the offense, having thrown for 1,542 yards with 5 touchdowns. However, his 9 interceptions are a concern that the Colts need to address.

Wide receiver Keenan Allen is another key player, with 36 receptions for 325 yards. His experience and playmaking ability will be crucial against the Cowboys' defense.

Injury Concerns

The Colts' injury report is a cause for concern, with several key players on the injured reserve list. Arden Key and Alec Pierce are among those who will miss the upcoming game.

Additionally, Anthony Gould, Justin Walley, and Bryce Boettcher are questionable for the game, which could impact the Colts' depth and strategy.

Betting Trends

• The Colts have a 5-2 over/under record as underdogs in their last 7 regular season games.
• In their last 7 away games, they have a 5-2 against the spread record.
• After a loss, the Colts have a 5-2 over/under record in their last 7 games.
• Overall, they are 6-3 on the over/under in their last 9 regular season games.

Cowboys Aim to Turn the Tide Against the Colts

Colts Offensive Overview

The Indianapolis Colts have shown a balanced offensive approach this season, with a mix of passing and rushing strategies. Their offense will rely heavily on the performance of their key players to exploit the Dallas Cowboys' defensive weaknesses.

The Colts have faced challenges with consistency, which could impact their ability to sustain drives against a Dallas defense that ranks 32nd in opponent offensive yards allowed per game.

Key Players to Watch

Quarterback play will be critical for the Colts, as they look to capitalize on the Cowboys' defensive vulnerabilities. The Colts will need their signal-caller to make smart decisions and protect the football against a Dallas defense that is ranked 9th in passing interceptions.

Running back performance is also pivotal, given the Cowboys' 32nd rank in opponent rushing yards per game. A strong ground game could help the Colts control the clock and keep Dallas' potent offense off the field.

Defensive Challenges

Defensively, the Colts will need to focus on containing the Cowboys' high-powered passing attack, led by Dak Prescott. With Dallas averaging 247.9 passing yards per game, the Colts' secondary will be tested.

The Colts' defensive front must apply pressure to disrupt Prescott's rhythm, as he ranks 5th in the league for passing yards. This task is crucial to minimizing big plays from Dallas' receiving corps.

Injury Concerns

Injuries have been a concern for the Colts, impacting their depth and performance on both sides of the ball. Key players' availability could be a deciding factor in their ability to compete against Dallas.

The Colts must adapt and find contributions from their roster to fill any gaps caused by injuries, particularly in crucial positions like their offensive line and secondary.

Betting Trends

• Colts have been competitive in games with totals of 50 or more points.
• They have struggled in recent away games, needing improved performance on the road.
• Indianapolis has shown resilience when playing as an underdog in previous matchups.
• The Colts need to improve their record after losses to gain confidence moving forward.

Colts vs Cowboys Prediction: Over 51.5

The Dallas Cowboys' offense ranks 7th in scoring, averaging 27.4 points per game. With their strong offensive production and the Colts' defensive struggles, giving up 27.8 points per game (28th rank), a high-scoring game is likely.

The Indianapolis Colts have shown a tendency to go over in recent games, hitting the over in 6 of their last 9 regular season matchups. Their defense has struggled significantly, ranking 28th in opponent scoring, which should allow the Cowboys to capitalize on their offensive opportunities.

Given the Cowboys' potent offense and the Colts' defensive vulnerabilities, both teams should have ample scoring opportunities. The Colts' status as 5.5-point underdogs does not diminish their potential to contribute to the scoreline, especially playing at home in Lucas Oil Stadium.

In this matchup, expect a high-scoring affair with both teams finding the end zone frequently. This will push the game over the projected total of 51.5 points.

• Colts vs Cowboys Prediction: Over 51.5
• Colts vs Cowboys Score: Cowboys 34 - Colts 28

Disclaimer: Knup Predictions are for entertainment and informational purposes only. Must be 21+ where applicable. Please gamble responsibly. If you or someone you know has a gambling problem, call 1-800-GAMBLER.